Some common misconceptions about the Edinburgh Property market are confronted by the experts at Neilsons Solicitors and Estate Agents.
Buying or selling a home can be life-changing. Where we choose to live can have a huge impact on our lifestyle, wellbeing and, of course, our finances. So, when it comes to making a move, good advice matters.
Yet in an increasingly digital world, it’s easy to turn to social media, friends and family, or outdated experiences for guidance. The trouble is that the Edinburgh and Lothians property market has changed considerably over the past 20 years and particularly since the Covid-19 pandemic. With the average UK homeowner staying put for around 17 years, there’s a good chance that the market, and the way properties are bought and sold, has changed since you last moved. Many local people will remember picking up the ESPC Property Pages or queueing at the George Street showroom to collect property schedules. Today, buyers have an abundance of information available instantly online, fundamentally changing the journey from property search to sale.
Of course, every transaction is different. The right approach depends not only on the property itself, but on the circumstances of the people buying and selling it. That’s why tailored professional advice is always worthwhile.
But if you’re not quite at that stage yet, the team at Neilsons Solicitors and Estate Agents is here to bust some of the most common myths about buying and selling property in Edinburgh and the Lothians.
Myth 1: All properties go to a Closing Date
If you find a property you’d love to buy, sitting back and waiting for the seller to set a Closing Date isn’t necessarily the best strategy. In reality, and shown by ESPC statistics, only around one in four properties currently goes to a Closing Date. Buyers are frequently making offers earlier rather than waiting and sellers may have very good reasons for considering them. For example, if a seller has already found their next home and is part of a chain, an opportunity to negotiate on a strong offer from a buyer who is ready to proceed can be extremely attractive. Achieving the best possible price will always matter, but price isn’t the only consideration. Certainty, timing and a buyer’s position can all have significant value.
So, rather than assuming there will eventually be a Closing Date, serious buyers should take advice and be prepared to act when the right property comes along.
Myth 2: Properties always sell for 10–20% over the Home Report value or asking price
Edinburgh has long been an extremely desirable place to live. It’s also a geographically compact city with a finite supply of homes in many sought-after locations, so particularly desirable properties can command substantial premiums. In some cases, homes may sell for 15–25% above their Home Report value. But that certainly doesn’t mean every property will.
There is no standard percentage that buyers can simply add to a Home Report valuation to arrive at the likely selling price. In fact, ESPC data shows that, so far in 2026, 73.5% of properties have sold for at least their Home Report value. Put another way, more than one in four has sold for less.
Across the local market, the average amount paid over Home Report value has been around 2% for the past couple of years. But averages only tell part of the story. The eventual selling price can be influenced by everything from the presentation and marketing of the property to buyer demand, competition, location and the seller’s individual circumstances.
For sellers, being prepared to achieve around Home Report value can be a sensible starting point and can regard anything over that level a welcome bonus. For buyers, getting advice from your own solicitor before making an offer is invaluable. They can help you assess the property, the market and an appropriate offer.
It’s also worth remembering that the selling agent acts for the seller, so they should not be advising a buyer how much to offer. One of the strengths of the Scottish property system is that buyers can obtain independent advice from their own solicitor when making an offer.
Myth 3: You don’t need a solicitor
This one is straightforward: you cannot complete the purchase or sale of a property in Scotland without a solicitor.
You could, theoretically, put your own For Sale board in the garden and choose not to use a professional estate agent. But the legal transfer of the property will still require solicitors acting for the buyer and seller and, in some circumstances, there may also be additional legal work relating to the mortgage lender too. Given that your home is likely to be your largest financial asset, professional guidance throughout the process and particularly at the very outset can be enormously valuable.
That’s one of the advantages of using a Solicitor Estate Agent. Firms such as Neilsons bring estate agency and legal expertise together under one roof, are regulated by the Law Society of Scotland and, as Chartered Members of ESPC, can market properties through the leading portal for local buyers.
Myth 4: ESPC is old-fashioned
ESPC may be a long-established Edinburgh institution, but that doesn’t make it old-fashioned. The days of relying on printed property schedules, like Rolodexes and Filofaxes are long gone. Today, ESPC.com provides a modern online property search experience and is the only property portal where buyers can immediately download Home Reports.
For firms such as Neilsons that advertise across all the major property portals, ESPC generates more than four times as many leads as Rightmove or Zoopla. ESPC Exclusive also gives buyers the opportunity to discover certain properties there first. Independent market research has also identified ESPC as the number one port of call for local buyers and sellers.
More importantly, ESPC is much more than a website. It represents around 130 member firms of Solicitor Estate Agents, bringing together generations of local knowledge and expertise. Buyers and sellers can access that expertise through articles, its magazine, podcasts, the George Street Property Lounge, at in person seminars and other resources.
So, when you’re selling a home in Edinburgh, perhaps the better question isn’t “Why should I advertise on ESPC?” but “Why would I want to miss out on that audience?”
Myth 5: Your choice of agent doesn’t matter – the house will sell itself
In a strong market such as Edinburgh, it’s easy to confuse “there is demand for property” with “every property will automatically achieve the best possible result”. They are very different things.
Selling a home successfully involves much more than uploading a listing and waiting for enquiries. Finding a buyer isn’t necessarily the same as achieving the optimum combination of price, speed and certainty. A good agent understands the local market, buyer behaviour, presentation, pricing, marketing and negotiation and knows how to bring those elements together to create competition and secure the strongest possible outcome.
So, the question isn’t simply whether you or a low-cost online agent could sell your home. The more useful question is whether an experienced local agent could sell it for more, achieve a more secure transaction, or find the right buyer more efficiently. ESPC Solicitor Estate Agents have been shown to achieve selling prices around 2% higher than non-ESPC agents. On a £400,000 sale, 2% represents £8,000. On a £750,000 property, it’s £15,000. Against figures like those, relatively small differences in estate agency fees can become much less significant than differences in performance.
It’s also why “we sold it in 24 hours” isn’t necessarily proof of outstanding estate agency. Sometimes an exceptionally quick sale means the strategy worked perfectly. In other cases, it can mean the property was priced too cautiously and an opportunity to generate greater competition was missed.
The important question isn’t simply “Did it sell?” It’s “Did the agent maximise the market opportunity?” And for Edinburgh sellers, we believe ESPC exposure should be a fundamental part of doing exactly that.
Myth 6: You need one point of contact who can handle everything
Having one point of contact sounds reassuringly personal. But one point of contact can also become one point of failure.
Selling a home involves a surprisingly broad range of specialist skills: valuation, marketing, photography and presentation, administration, buyer management, negotiation and, ultimately, specialist legal work. It’s unrealistic to expect one person to be an expert in every one of those areas. Think about building a house. You wouldn’t expect one tradesperson to be your architect, builder, plumber, electrician, joiner and decorator. You’d want the right specialist handling each part of the job, with everyone working together towards the same outcome. Selling a property is much the same.
Great service doesn’t have to mean one person doing every job. It means having the right person doing each job, with a joined-up team taking responsibility for the whole transaction.
Myth 7: Buyers can see past poor presentation
It’s tempting to think buyers will simply look beyond clutter, dated décor or poor photographs and recognise a property’s potential. Unfortunately, many never get that far.
More than 70% of buyers begin their property search on a mobile phone. They’re scrolling through listings, looking at relatively small images and making rapid judgements about homes before deciding whether they’re worth investigating further. That represents one of the biggest changes in property marketing since the move away from print. Today’s buyers expect plenty of high-quality photographs, floorplans, video, 360° tours and easy access to the Home Report, often before they’re prepared to leave the sofa and arrange a viewing.
That makes good presentation enormously important. It gives your property the best chance of standing out online, attracting more viewers and, ultimately, creating competition between interested buyers. And getting buyers through the front door matters. An in-person viewing allows someone to develop an emotional connection with a home and appreciate qualities such as ceiling height, natural light, proportions and atmosphere, all things that can be difficult to communicate fully through an online listing. Your home doesn’t need to be state-of-the-art to sell well. But it should be clean, appealing and presented in a way that helps buyers imagine themselves living there.
If you’re unsure where to begin, Neilsons offers free in-person pre-sale appraisals, including advice on how best to prepare and present your property for the market. After all, the way that works perfectly for living in your home day to day isn’t always the way that shows it at its very best to potential buyers. And where a little extra help could make a difference, we can also recommend trusted local professionals, from declutterers to decorators, to help get your home ready for its moment in the spotlight.
The Edinburgh property market is always evolving, and what was true the last time you moved or what worked for a friend, neighbour or someone on social media, may not be right for you. Every move is different, which is why good, local advice can make such a difference. Whether you’re thinking about buying, selling or simply wondering what your next move might look like, the Neilsons team is always happy to have a friendly, no-obligation chat and help you understand your options.
Advertorial feature
