French U20s overcome battling Scots at Netherdale

 EdinReport SU20vFU20-2

In the second of the RBS U20 matches Scotland played in Galashiels, they went down fighting to a strong French side that dominated large parts of the match were but were never quite able to run away with it.


That dominance started from the off with the French forwards penetrating deep into the Scottish 22, but they had to be content with a penalty award which No 10, Brandon Fujardo (top photo) sent wide. The Scots then came back and 15 minutes into the match were awarded their own penalty up around the 22, which No 10, Ben Chalmers scored to give the Scots a 3-0 lead. Less than 10 minutes later it was France’s turn to add points to the scoreboard. Their No 8, Francois Cros, left Scotland’s Malcolm clutching at thin air as the lock sprinted off upfield. His pass to scrum half, Anthony Meric had the ball close to the Scot’s line and his final pass to Fujardo saw the stand-off crashing over for the try. Fujardo then converted to give France a 7-3 lead.


Although Scotland had a period of possession – and a missed penalty – following the score, France gradually began to push them back and a series of kicks and mistakes lead to another French penalty from Fujardo in the 33rd minute to extend their lead to 10-3. The last few minutes of the half were played out in the middle of the pitch, and, although Scotland did penetrate the French defence up to their 22, there was no further scoring and the sides went in at 10-3 to France.


The second half carried on where the first had left off with the French side in the ascendancy. Although they were forced into a couple of errors, they didn’t look under too much pressure and an early penalty saw Meric extend the lead by three to 13-3. It then took the French side just over six minutes to score their second try of the match. Driving the ball deep into the Scots’ 22, they probed and poked at the defence before pressure told and a pick-and-go from a ruck had No 3, Tommy Raynaud over near the corner. Meric missed the kick, but the score was now out to 18-3 with still over 25 minutes to play.

EdinReport SU20vFU20-1

And it was 25 minutes where the Scots came to the fore. Good passing and running, coupled with penalties against the French, left the Scots within a few metres of the 22. Choosing to go for the corner, the home side won the line out and drove up to the French line. Stopped short, the ball was quickly recycled and a couple of drives later, No 4, Andrew Cramond (eventual Man-of-the-Match) was driven over for the try. However, the conversion attempt hit the post so the score was 18-8 to France with 21 minutes of the second half played. With their tails up, Scotland now took the game to the French. Another 10 minutes in and they had set up another series of rucks near the French line, but getting nowhere, the ball was passed out to centre Blair Hutchison. He then lofted a neat kick into the opposition goal area where it looked like an easy catch for the defender, but under pressure Damien Hoyland, he lost the ball and Hoyland then pounced on the loose ball to touch down for Scotland’s second try. This kick was missed as well so the score now stood at 18-13 to France.


The remainder of the match was played mostly in the French half, with the Scots pressing, but with no further scoring the match ended with victory to the visitors, 18-13.


This was a better display from the young Scots side than that against England, but they are still missing the last, wee bit to become regular winners, but, under the tutelage of Sean Lineen, things have moved on and he now has a ‘two year’ squad he can work with into the future.

Images from the match will be uploaded here within the next few days.


  1. Why is Lineen working with a two year squad? I think he has got it all wrong. This side is clearly lacking a commanding stand-off. Chalmers turn is next year and as such he should be, and ought to be, shadowing the likes of Ben Cooper (who shadowed Tommy Allan last season). Instead Lineen brings in two 18 yr old 10s (incidently where was Horne after being brought back in?) who clearly do not have the temperament or commanding stature of the like of Cooper (from what I’ve seen the past 4 seasons).
    Lineen cannot keep protecting his position by saying he is building for the following year. This does nothing to aid the careers of the 19/20 year olds that have up to now been invested in by the SRU through the age grade system.
    The Under 20s are looking like they will not win a single match in this years 6 nations and I fear for the junior world cup and indeed our involvement the following year if we get smashed over in NZ and lose our placing in the Tournament. That is a real issue and as such, Lineen should go. Sorry for the rant and yes, some of the lads did very well last night, but key areas with inexperience will not do.

  2. Feel free to rant away Mr. Forster, but we at The ER don’t know….
    However, I’m not sure if Sean Lineen will be reading this so I would suggest you direct your comments – which are fair enough – to Mr. S. Lineen, c/o Scottish Rugby………
    To add to your ‘fears’, while some of our U20s are still playing at Scottish club level they are going to find it hard to compete against, effectively, full time professional players from other nations. Nature of the beast, I’m afraid.

  3. I’m not suggesting Lineen does read these articles/postings, and as such, my comments aren’t directed at him, they are meant to be read by your readers. I absolutely agree with your statement regarding our lads playing effectively full-time professionals and that, coupled with our considerably smaller player base in which to choose from will always make things difficult for the age grade players. It’s clearly the system that is wrong and until we have a proper academy set-up we will get no where. But surely we cannot allow our lads to be demoralized enough so that they either move abroad for regular, better standard of rugby, or heaven forbid stop playing the game altogether. These are my worries. Let’s for heaven sake play a team that could at least win a game and not keep saying we’re building for next season.
    I’m never normally this negative, but we are in crises here, at both senior and age grade.
    I really do hope that we can salvage something from the final game against the Welsh

Comments are closed.