Guns N’ Roses bassist and co-songwriter Duff McKagan arrived in Scotland after a prolific solo writing period.

The beating punk rock heart of Guns N’ Roses has a style all of his own. Still, at the same time, it’s not difficult to imagine Axl Rose singing while Slash solos all over opener Forgiveness but respect to Duff while there’s currently no sign of his band putting out an album he’s brought out two strong solo studio records in recent years while touring around small clubs capturing something of the spirit of those halcyon days from the mid to late 1980s.

He remains effortlessly cool in a black shirt and jacket with aviator shades, not unlike the ones depicted on the skull illustration from the Appetite For Destruction cover. The audience is an eclectic mix of new and younger fans as well as GN’R diehards; they all sing along to the likes of the country-tinged Chip Away, an earworm that demonstrates McKagan’s ability to write a catchy tune. Rod Stewart should have a shot at singing this one if he ever wants to return to Faces style rock n’ roll.

Duff was responsible for some of the best songwriting from Guns N’ Roses Use Your Illusion era, his track So Fine is a case in point and the likes of Tenderness suggest that vintage. The biggest shift is seeing him trade his white Fender P bass for a Gibson Hummingbird while resembling an alt-country troubadour on I Don’t Know. During the middle of the set, he switches to an electric white Telecaster perfectly matched for a version of I Fought The Law. It’s followed by an electrifying You’re Crazy that recalls the Steven Adler last gang in town era Guns N’ Roses. Mike Musburger on drums plays slightly behind the beat and remains on just the right side of not letting everything fall apart just before Tim Dijulio rips into a blistering solo.

The Garage by now is a sweaty and wild sea of bodies moving as much as they can in this cramped venue. Duff carries the spirit of Johnny Thunders with You Can’t Put Your Arms Around A Memory, a song which feels as much his as the late New York Doll. It segues beautifully into Bowie’s Heroes; its solid version that summons the same motivating force of the original. It encourages one older gentleman with a long white mane to start head-banging in the front row.

During the epic end coda of Don’t Look Behind You, McKagan jumps into the front row to press flesh with his “Glasgow cousins”, some pat him on the back, others offer a handshake while he raises his fists enraptured by the moment. The punk rock beating heart of Guns N’Roses still pumps and clearly leaves a bit of itself with a compelling performance that lifted the sprits of everyone in room.

A new name has been introduced to the property scene – but with well kent faces behind it.

Niksen is a new residential property agent which will be open seven days a week in Stockbridge and is founded by businessman Ronnie Napier with former Coulters and Savills agent, Ben Di Rollo. The name comes from the Dutch concept of slowing down and enjoying life which will be carried over into the buying and selling of homes. The team – Managing Partner, Ben Di Rollo, Chairman, Ronnie Napier, Media Specialist, David Wilkinson, Sales Specialist, Rebecca Booth, and Valuation Specialist, Claire Barrett – will focus on the client and their needs in an “innovative and personal” way.

The company will have in-house photographers, social media and marketing experts who will all work together to create a strategy for each property. The business will be run as a partnership allowing them to recruit “the best talent”. With each member of the team invested in the success of the business, the hope is that this will translate into success in every transaction.

Ben Di Rollo, said: ”Our goal with Niksen is to provide a service that truly puts people at the heart of every transaction. We believe in doing things differently as beautifully styled homes and remarkable architecture across Scotland deserve to be showcased with the care and quality they inspire. By capturing these properties with exceptional photography and promoting them across the right channels, we maximise exposure, enhancing both visibility and value for every client. Our mission is to ensure that the dedication and effort our clients pour into their homes are rightfully rewarded—that’s what motivates us.

“We showcase not only the home but the lifestyle that comes with it. Whether it’s a countryside retreat or a city dwelling, we make sure the property is presented to the widest, most informed audience by taking a more targeted approach than marketing the property itself. Our focus on in-house resources means we control the quality of our marketing assets such as photography and videos captured in our own style, which we lend us to achieve more editorial features and far better engagement on social media.” 

Ronnie Napier said: “The Edinburgh market is buoyant but bound by convention in a sense of approach, our aim is to add value at every touchpoint and remove some of the barriers that both private sellers and new developers face in terms of marketing. Clients can benefit from a one-stop-shop approach where every detail from marketing, the practicalities of readying a property for sale to removals to de-cluttering, it’s all managed by us without hidden costs. We have many new ways in which we can assist new build developers, but our most exciting tool enables us to offer bespoke branding, plot selectors, CGIs and an end-to-end marketing strategy delivered in-house against a single agreed fee.” 

The firm will use modern software providing targeted marketing solutions working from their office at 32 North West Circus Place formerly occupies by Coulters.

Open from 9am – 5.30 pm Monday to Friday. Phones are open 8am – 7pm Monday – Friday and 10am – 4pm at the weekends. 

Ben Di Rollo, Partner, is available on 0131 287 5500 or visit the website here.

West Edinburgh Stingrays led the Edinburgh challenge as they finished third to an all conquering host side from Dunfermline in The Brian Campbell Autumn water polo cup for under-14s

The tournament commemorates a much respected coach from Dunfermine who died in 2019.

Runners up were Stirling with Portobello and Warrender fifth and sixth respectively in the nine team competition.

Murray Simpson from West Edinburgh Stingrays was the tournament’s top goal scorer with an impressive 21 goals from four  games.

Organiser Ali Campbell says: “It’s crazy how much the tournament has grown.

“We also have the boys event on November 30^th – December 1st where Portobello are looking to defend the title.”

The newest attraction at Hillend is promised to be the “ride of your life” by Midlothian Council.

Now you can see the full scope of the white knuckle coaster which is 980 metres from top to bottom with a vertical drop of 170 metres. Riders can slow their carts down if they get too scared – and if you really only want to have a virtual experience then see the video below.

The ride is open on Saturdays and Sundays and will be open during the school holiday week from 14 October to 21 October inclusive.

Book here using the Midlothian Leisure app.

ALL PHOTOS Craig Duncan

The Stockbridge-based charity which provides care and support for older people is asking for help in their Winter Warmer appeal.

LifeCare which has its café and hub on Cheyne Street is issuing a plea for locals to use its café for coffee and lunch or to make donations to help them continue with their vital work.

The charity says that the high prices for energy and cuts to winter fuel allowance for some pensioners will make this a difficult time. LifeCare continues to experience rising demand for their free and subsidised services.

The services include meals on wheels delivering hot freshly cooked two course meals to older people at home, home help services including cleaning, shopping and prescription collections, wellbeing activities and hot drinks at the charity hub. They also run their free Saturday Social warm space providing hot food, activities and companionship from their Cheyne Street community hub every week. But the continuing increase in demand means that the charity requires more funds. The charity is calling on local people and businesses to get involved and give a donation to help deliver support to those that need it most this winter.

Sarah van Putten, Chief Executive of LifeCare said: “Local older people right here in Edinburgh face a very difficult winter ahead.  With the 10% increase on energy costs, continued high food prices and a reduction in benefits, it will be devastating for many. Last year we delivered over 5,000 free meals to those living on a low income.  This year we anticipate needing to grow the service by a further 30% to help meet growing demand for this important service as more local older people struggle. 

“We urgently need the support from local people and local businesses, to enable LifeCare to deliver services such as this which make a real difference to those struggling most.  

“Thanks to our services, older people keep well in their homes, they have a warm place to visit, hot nutritious food to eat, have company to look forward to and are able to get out and about to activities safely.  Over 75% of the people we support live alone, rising to over 85% of our Meals on Wheels clients.  And as many of our clients can’t leave their homes unaided, they would go for a very long time without any contact without our support.  

“The frustration is that we know we can deliver the care that people want and need, but we are facing increased costs too. We are asking local people and businesses to consider giving a one-off or regular gift through our Winter Warmer appeal.  Donations can be made on our website, or alternatively people can come along to our community café on Cheyne Street to pledge their support.  Even choosing to have your coffee or lunch from our café will help us to deliver the care local older people need to ensure they continue to thrive at home.” 

All money raised through Winter Warmer will go directly towards supporting older people in the city.  

https://www.lifecare-edinburgh.org.uk/ or call 0131 343 0940 to chat with the friendly team. 

The organisers of the Scottish Album of the Year (SAY) Award, the Scottish Music Industry Association, has announced the short list of ten albums.

The winner of the Album of the Year award will be announced on 24 October. In addition Martin Bennett’s final studio album, “Grit” will be announced as the winner of the 2024 Modern Scottish Classic Award. Tickets are available for the evening event at the Albert Halls in Stirling.

The Sound of Young Scotland winner will also be announced on the evening from the five finalists Alice Faye, Dillon Barrie, Goliath, Pippa Blundell and Spyres.

Music fans voted over 72 hours from the long list and have produced the ten most popular albums. Kathryn Williams and Withered Hand won the public vote with the other nine albums chosen by the judging panel.

The SAY Award winner receives a prize of £20,000, the Sound of Young Scotland winner will receive £10,000 to help them create a debut album.

The SAY Award Shortlist for 2024, in alphabetical order, is: 

Arab Strap I’m totally fine with it don’t give a f*** anymore

Barry Can’t Swim When Will We Land?

Becky Sikasa The Writings and the Pictures and the Song

corto.alto Bad With Names

Dead Pony IGNORE THIS

Kathryn Williams & Withered Hand Willson Williams

Lucia & The Best Boys Burning Castles

Rachel Sermanni Dreamer Awake

rEDOLENT dinny greet

Theo Bleak Pain

Robert Kilpatrick, CEO and Creative Director of the Scottish Music Industry Association (SMIA), said: “Congratulations to the 10 incredible albums that have made The SAY Award Shortlist, as well as to our Sound of Young Scotland Award finalists and this year’s Modern Scottish Classic Award winner; Martyn Bennett’s outstanding, innovative and much-loved record ‘Grit’. This is a fantastic representation of the strength and diversity of Scottish music – past, present and future.

“In what has been – and continues to be – an incredibly challenging time for Scotland’s cultural sector, The SAY Award’s role in celebrating, promoting and rewarding artistic endeavour is more important than ever. Culture is our identity; it’s how we understand ourselves, our place in the world and how we connect with each other. It tells the stories of life in Scotland and is essential to our collective and individual well-being. By championing the incredible musical output of our nation, we share our stories with the rest of the world and find new ways to connect.

“Scottish music not only enriches who we are but also contributes significantly to our economy, generating £195 million in 2018 alone, with music tourism adding £406 million. These figures show the profound impact of music, not just culturally, but in creating jobs, driving growth and funding vital public services. Without sustained and increased investment, however, the future for many of our artists and cultural organisations remains uncertain. It’s therefore essential that we continue to advocate for the long-term commitment that Scottish culture both needs and deserves.

“The SMIA is proud of its ongoing commitment to the continued value of music and the arts in Scotland, and The SAY Award is a vital part of this work. A huge thank you to our partners for their invaluable support, and we look forward to an unforgettable celebration at Stirling’s Albert Halls on Thursday 24 October.”

SAY Award Ceremony tickets are on sale now via www.sayaward.com £18 + booking fee

Two Lothians’ golfers have been selected to represent Europe against the United States in the Phoenix Cup, a competition for players with various disabilities to be held over St Andrews’ Old, New and Jubilee courses from October 28-30.

They are amputees Gordon Maclay and Adam Storrie.

Royal Musselburgh life member Gordon is 61-years-old and has been playing golf since aged eight.

However, in July 2007, he had a motorcycle accident in which he severely damaged both ankles.

Gordon says: “After a right ankle fusion in 2010 I was able to get back to some kind of normality (and) I then became a Tour caddy initially working on the Seniors Staysure Tour with Steen Tinning from Denmark and later on the Legends  Tour with Rog Chapman from England. He was USPGA/US Open champion which allowed me to travel to the US for major tournaments.

“Unfortunately after a few years I started having recurring problems with my right ankle, struggling with severe pain and the onset of arthritis.

“I along with the medical support team made the decision to have my right leg amputated below the knee.

“This was done in September 2022. The year 2023 was an eye opening year as an amputee for me. After just a four month rehabilitation programme I was back out playing golf again.

“I am honoured to have been asked to play for Team Europe.”

Adam Storrie, 69, , from the Greenburn Club, is Team Europe’s co-captain. He is a below knee amputee and says: “I lost my left foot due to an accident and work and found the Scottish Disability Golf and Curling Club by chance. It has enhanced my life and golf.”

Joining Adam in captaincy duties is Jim Gales, MBE from Fife, who founded the Scottish Disability Golf Club in 2004 and helped generate the Phoenix Cup while blind.

Jim said: “I have had the honour of leading 13 international squads, have played in over 100 Open Championships in fourteen nations, winning 17 individual titles, including the British Open on three occasions and representing both Scotland  and Canada at curling internationals.”

• For more about the Phoenix Cup and its inspirational participants go to this website

Edinburgh is preparing to take the spotlight as the host city for the Global Fair Trade Festival from 29 to 31 August, 2025.

This international event, which will bring together Fair Trade advocates, producers, and businesses from around the world, is a significant opportunity for the city to further solidify its leadership in the global movement. Before arriving in Edinburgh, the festival will first be held in South Africa on the 20 to 22 September in Drankenstein. It’s a country where Fair Trade plays a crucial role in addressing systemic poverty and creating sustainable livelihoods. South Africa’s engagement in Fair Trade has set an inspiring example, one that Edinburgh hopes to build upon when it hosts the event.

The conference will focus on how Fair Trade intersects with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), highlighting the importance of ethical trade in achieving poverty reduction, decent work, gender equality, and climate action. Edinburgh’s own contribution to Fair Trade has been growing steadily, and the 2025 festival promises to boost its reputation as a global Fair Trade city. Fair Trade Fortnight is also coming in as it takes place between 9th and 22nd September, 2024 as it commemorates the Fair Trade Mark’s 30th anniversary.

I’ve been a vocal advocate for Fair Trade and ethical working conditions. As a key member of the Cross-Party Group on Bangladesh, I was spoken to about the difficult conditions faced by workers as I heard their stories during our trip to Bangladesh. The factories I visited were overcrowded, unsafe, and offered extremely low wages. There is an urgent need for intervention to improve these conditions, and I believe Fair Trade can provide a real solution as it ensures a minimum price guarantee and promotes transparency in supply chains, protecting workers from unpredictable market fluctuations, and this stark difference was noted in the Fair Trade factories.

This would offer stability to Bangladeshi workers, many of whom currently struggle to survive on inconsistent incomes. Additionally, Fair Trade provides a Fair Trade Premium which are extra funds that are reinvested into local communities for essential projects such as healthcare, education, and infrastructure. This premium could be especially beneficial in Bangladesh, where it could help build flood defenses and improve community resilience against climate change, an ongoing threat to the country. Fair pay for garment workers was on the agenda.

Changing weather patterns bringing more storms have forced West Lothian Council to draw up rules on issuing sandbags as the risk of flooding grows. 

Councillors have now agreed where, and who, will qualify for sandbag protection.  While there is no statutory duty to prevent flooding in properties, one councillor suggested we could all do our bit to improve flood resilience by following the Netherlands. 

The Dutch introduced a competition last year called Tegelwippen “tile-flipping” where councils encouraged households to re-green their gardens and dig up paved areas to improve natural drainage.  

Many Dutch councils now operate their own “Tegel taxis”- lorries which collect unwanted paving slabs.  

Intense competition between communities has seen a re-greening of a land in which the lowest point is 22 ft below sea level.   As Councillor Pauline Stafford told the Local Democracy Reporting Service, the Dutch “know a thing or two about flooding”.   

Councillor Stafford, the depute leader of the SNP group, who has lived in the Netherlands, suggested adopting the technique as councillors heard about the new sandbag policy. 

A report to the Executive highlighted how much of the recent flooding in areas such as Bathgate last October had been caused by storms which overwhelmed Victorian drainage systems. 

The report, compiled by Chris Chalmers, a council flood risk engineer said: “In recent years there has been an increasing trend of exceptionally high intensity rainstorms. The magnitude of these is such that the capacity of drainage systems become quickly overwhelmed causing flooding of the surrounding area.  

“Historic drainage systems do not have the capacity to cope with excessive rainfall events which inevitably causes them to surcharge, resulting in flooding.” 

It added: “Whilst run-off from heavy rainfall will eventually find its way into watercourses, a large contributor to flooding of properties is often surface water run-off from either cultivated or developed areas.” 

Councillor Stafford and Linlithgow councillors Pauline Orr and Sally Pattle had attended an event staged by the River Almond Action Group (RAAG) and West Lothian Climate Action Network (WLCAN) on Saturday. 

 She added: “We are facing a huge change in the way that water moves around. There was a lot of discussion about the issue of run-off and how much pressure it is putting on the historic drains system. 

 “We were chatting about a campaign that’s running across the Netherlands called Tegelwippen where they are encouraging everybody to lift their grey infrastructure in their gardens to make their gardens more climate resistant. I think if we did that on a grand scale we would do our bit to prevent the need for sandbags as a last resort because we are going to see more and more damage.  

“I think we should all be lifting our slabs and planting up gardens.” 

Councillor Pattle said: “That sounds amazing. Hooray for the Dutch.” 

The flood risk report stressed that householders have primary responsibility to protect their homes during floods. The council’s primary responsibility is to protect against loss of life and also keep roads clear and protect public buildings.  

 The report highlighted: “The primary responsibility for avoiding or managing flood risk lies with land and property owners, certain public bodies [Scottish Water, SEPA] are expected to take a proactive role in managing and, where achievable, lowering overall flood risk.”  

“The council has no statutory duty to prevent properties from flooding, but will help residents and communities, as resources allow in line with this policy.”  

It detailed seven conditions which would need to be met for the council to release its stockpile of 3,000 sandbags.  

These include:-  

To prevent loss of life or injury.  

Maintain emergency services access.  

Secure road safety. 

Protect facilities i.e. hospitals; emergency service facilities; publicly owned social care facilities.  

Protect schools and other public buildings.  

Protect  council owned residential property in flood risk areas. 

Protect business/commercial property.  

Mr Chalmers added: “During a flood event, West Lothian Council will give priority to its statutory obligations. However, every effort will be made, where resources allow, to supply filled sandbags to properties that are at imminent risk of flooding.   

“A sandbag stock will be maintained where possible and kept across depots for emergency use only. Sandbags will not be delivered in advance of a flood event.  

“This ‘first rapid response’ to flooding emergencies is essentially a ‘self-help’ exercise where affected proprietors would be expected to put measures in place to protect themselves from flooding.” 

By Stuart Sommerville, Local Democracy Reporter 

Police in East Lothian are appealing for the public’s help to track down the owner of a bicycle. 

Officers have released a photograph of the bike which was recently found in the Musselburgh area. 

They suspect that it had previously been stolen. 

A Police spokesperson said: The bicycle pictured was found recently in the Musselburgh area in circumstances where it is believed to have been stolen. 
 
If you are the rightful owner of this bike or have any relevant information please contact 101 and quote incident number 1336 of 12th September 2024. 

Emergency services cordoned off a main street in Portobello earlier on Wednesday after masonry from an upper floor of a tenement crashed to the ground.

Large chunks of sandstone, apparently from a window lintel, could be seen on the pavement below as a police officer cordoned off the area.

Bath Street, running from the High Steet to the Promenade is one of the seaside town’s busiest thoroughfare.

The Edinburgh Reporter has contacted Police Scotland and Scottish Fire and Rescue Service for an update, but it is unknown whether any injuries were sustained.

Fire crews were seen working from platform ladders to remove rubble and make the building safe. Access to the Coop superstore and other local businesses was restricted.

A spokesperson for the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service said: “We were alerted at 3.20pm on Wednesday 2 October to reports of debris coming loose from a building on Bath Street in Portobello, Edinburgh.

“Operations Control mobilised two appliances, including a height appliance, to the scene.

“Firefighters ensured the area was made safe before leaving the scene.”

Colin Cornwall said: “A large chunk of red sandstone from around one of the windows of the flats above the Citizens Advice Bureau smashed to the ground.”

Another passerby said: “It was a pretty dramatic scene but everything was under control. It is one of Porty’s busiest streets with folk passing up and down to the beach so it’s very fortunate no one was hurt.”

When Pakistani families migrated to Scotland in the 1960s they adopted a novel form of communicating with their relatives at home – by recording messages on cassette tapes which were then posted back to Pakistan. And they awaited a reply by the same method either by post or dispatched with visitors returning to Scotland.

This is the subject of a new audio-visual exhibition at the Museum of Edinburgh which opens on Thursday. There are first hand interviews with those who can remember being involved – both in Pakistan and here in Scotland.

The tapes offered a cheaper alternative to making international telephone calls, and also provided a more accessible option for those unable to read or write letters. But the practice has since remained largely unknown to many, even within British-Pakistani communities, with many original tapes lost or later recorded over.

First launched in 2018, Tape Letters is a social archive project by Modus Arts, which aims to unearth, archive, and represent a portrait of this method of communication. A time when the telephone was communal, the tapes left room for intimacy in messages to loved ones. The exhibition also highlights the prominence of female voices.

Wajid Yaseen, Director of Modus Arts, said: “The Tape Letters project has turned out to be far more fruitful than I could have envisaged, and analysing the archive has felt akin to undertaking a sort of “sonic archaeology” – a deep dive into a wide range of fields and themes, including memory studies, linguistics, migration, discrimination, communication technologies, class and socio-economic dynamics, and many others. Although it has become a surprisingly complex social history project, it primarily demonstrates the deep and inherent need for people to communicate with each other in whatever way they can, wherever they’re originally from or wherever they find themselves in the world.” 

Culture and Communities Convener, Cllr Val Walker said: “How fortunate we are to have Tape Letters at Museum of Edinburgh this winter.

“We live in such modern times, where everyone is an instant call away no matter where they are in the world. You can only imagine the excitement felt when a tape would arrive from family members, loved ones and friends and their voice and stories would be heard through the speakers.

“Tape Letters is a touching exhibition that can be appreciated by all members of our diverse community. I encourage everyone to take the time to visit, listen and reflect.”

Faria Khan, from Glasgow, who contributed to the archive, said: “Dad used to turn the cassette player on and test it and, you know, he’d bang on the mic saying “testing, testing”. It was just such an exciting thing preparing to record something! Like, what are we doing here? He’d then explain to us that it was a message for the family back home in Pakistan.” 

Aqsa Mohammed, from Glasgow, also part of the exhibition, said: “My mum would listen to the tapes and tears would fall – she was always crying. Even when recording she would be crying. I’d get excited though. “Haan tape aayi!” [Alright! a tape has arrived!] It felt like a different feeling for us – a very emotional time. Emotional for her. Excitement for us.” 

On 8 October, the National Library of Scotland will host a special public talk featuring Wajid Yaseen and Tape Letters Scotland Project Coordinator, Syma Ahmed, where audiences will be invited to hear first-hand from the project team about their work, and the importance of archiving and preserving migrant stories for present and future generations. Serving to both broaden access to the project, and preserve these unique historical accounts, Tape Letters Scotland is set to launch a WebXR-based digital exhibition and specialised App this October, followed by a Podcast series later this year. 

Tape Letters Scotland Exhibition: 
At Museum of Edinburgh, Royal Mile.
3 October 2024 – 23 February 2025
 

Drivers are “fed up” with delays at Edinburgh’s Sheriffhall roundabout and are growing impatient over an “upgrade” promised six years ago, according to a Conservative councillor.

Cllr Graeme Bruce said the lack of progress on major works aimed at cutting traffic jams at the junction was “extremely disappointing,” adding the economic prosperity of the region “heavily relies on” the project going ahead.

The Pentland Hills councillor also questioned why it was taking so long for an independent report containing recommendations on how to proceed with the scheme to be made public.

Findings from a Public Local Inquiry (PLI) set up to consider more than 2,000 individual objections remain in the hands of Scottish Ministers, despite the report being completed a year ago.

The “flyover” at Sheriffhall would separate local traffic from motorway traffic, cutting peak journey times on the A720, and is a flagship project of the Edinburgh and South East Scotland City Regional Deal. This was signed in 2018 to deliver £1.3billion investment from the UK and Scottish Governments as well as the region’s six councils and other organisations.

Plans were approved in 2021, but soon derailed by objections. Climate campaigners warned that the changes would generate more traffic at a time when Transport Scotland wants to achieve a 20 per cent reduction in car kilometres by the end of the decade, while the significant roadworks would involve “immense carbon emissions”.

Cllr Bruce said: “Money was set aside back in 2018 as part of the Edinburgh and South East Scotland region Deal to make traffic move more freely at this junction.

“It is extremely disappointing to find that six years later there isn’t even a spade in the ground while traffic jams get longer and longer as the years progress.

“Over the last 30 years huge numbers of housing developments have sprung up on the south side of the city but also around the Lothians. People need their own transport at times, to get to their place of work or shopping or visiting relatives, and of course not forgetting the tourist and HGV traffic as well.

“A tram or other forms of public transport isn’t going to cut the mustard when somebody wants to bring home five bags of cement, several wooden posts, rails, and slats along with a bag of nails.”

Originally priced at £120 million, an updated cost of the improvements is yet to be announced, however it’s feared it could now be above £200m.

However The Scottish Government, which would be responsible for covering anything over the previously agreed funding package, remains “steadfast” in its commitment to the project, a recent meeting of stakeholders heard.

Paul Junik from Transport Scotland said the PLI report remained under “active consideration”.

He said: “It’s not unusual for complex road projects like this where there has been a significant number of objections for the period of time to elapse in terms of I think we’re at 11 months.

“Scottish Ministers’ commitment to this remains steadfast.

“The work is ongoing, active consideration is currently underway and as soon as possible that decision will be made by Scottish Ministers and as soon as a decision has been made they will be publishing the outcome of that review.”

East Lothian Council leader Norman Hampshire said: “The City Bypass is struggling because of that roundabout and the City Deal have got that as a flagship project.

“The City Deal are delivering lots of projects and this particular project is causing us not particularly good publicity, and it would be good if we could get at least some sort of timeframe.”

Cllr Hampshire added: “When the City Deal took this project on we had a budget of £120m, at that time when we were looking at this project we had estimated it could come in around £80m . . . this potentially could be £200m or more.”

Cllr Bruce continued: “Our citizens, not just in Edinburgh but around the Lothians, are fed up with the constant delays at Sheriffhall and indeed across the length of this road. Sorting this junction to get traffic moving again is absolutely imperative. The sooner you start, the sooner the better in my opinion.

 “Also, it is clear for everyone to see that it needs the lanes in each direction with the appropriate road infrastructure to keep the traffic moving. The economic prosperity of our city and surrounding areas heavily rely on the improvement of this junction and we cannot afford any more dither and delay.”

Uncertain future and objections

But the future of the Sheriffhall Roundabout remains uncertain and has stalled in recent years with a public inquiry being held. As at April 2024 the inquiry report has been with Scottish Ministers for six months with no announcement made as yet – and still no announcement today. 

When the Secretary of State for Scotland, the Rt Hon Ian Murray, spoke to The Edinburgh Reporter shortly after his appointment in July this year he agreed that the terms of some City Region Deals may have to be revisited. 

He said: “The problem of the city deals – particularly the early ones like the Edinburgh one is that inflation and construction costs have blown a lot of it out of the water unless it was started earlier. 

“So the Edinburgh Futures Institute, which was a part of that it started, it’s open. It’s fantastic, and a great resource for the city and for Scotland, going forward. But actually some of the other projects now might be unviable or requiring additional funding for them to happen.”

Cycle campaign group, Spokes has expressed concern over the provision for walking and cycling- which they feel would become worse not better. And Spokes have expressed their support for the group Sheriffhall Overarching Objectors (SHOO) which set up a crowdfunder (now closed) to raise funds for expert advice in connection with the inquiry.

The two campaigns joined together to produce a report to the public inquiry in 2023, with a legal team advising and cross examining Transport Scotland’s “tired evidence”.

SHOO set out their objections as these:

• The proposal would generate more traffic and contradicts Transport Scotland’s goal “A route map to achieve a 20 percent reduction in car kilometres by 2030.”
• The construction of the Scheme would involve immense carbon emissions, primarily through the consumption of diesel oil, concrete and steel, when immediate reductions in emissions are essential to avoid catastrophic climate change.
• In its operation, the scheme makes no significant or genuine contribution towards the rapid carbon reductions required to meet the targets of the Scottish Climate Change Act: building and operating it jeopardises any chance for Scotland to deliver net-zero as required by the Scottish Government’s own laws.
• The initial budget for the Scheme was £120 million, but with massive inflation in the building industry, the actual cost would likely be at least £200 million. Even if those sums are available for transport, given widespread poverty and the financial pressures on government, they could be far better spent on public transport and active travel.

Main story by Donald Turvill, Local Democracy Reporter.

The new operators of the Edinburgh Filmhouse have said its future “is not in question” after plans to boost revenue by installing a large advertising screen outside were refused for a third time.

This is despite a warning in the latest planning application that a further setback could “throw the future of the Filmhouse into doubt”.

A spokesperson for Filmhouse (Edinburgh) Ltd, the charity formed to rescue the cinema after its owners went bust two years ago, said revised plans with the LED screen removed had already been lodged.

And as planners have said the rest of the application, covering internal alterations including a complete refit and addition of a fourth small screen, is “acceptable,” it’s anticipated this will be approved in the coming weeks allowing work to commence.

Councillors voted 8-2 “with a heavy heart” to reject the advert display which would cover a large portion of the front of the b-listed Lothian Road building at a planning sub-committee on Wednesday, October 2.

After two previous refusals the Filmhouse altered plans to make the screen transparent and reduce its size to 9.5m by 5.9m in a bid to get them over the line.

The latest application stated: “At the end of the day it becomes a decision of what is best for Edinburgh, approve listed building consent and consent to display an advertisement to ensure a thriving revitalised Filmhouse with an external screen to provide advertising revenue helping to secure the sustainability of the Filmhouse or refuse listed building consent and consent to display an advertisement and throw the future of the Filmhouse into doubt.”

At the meeting planning officers said: “The justification for the screen has been made in respect of the funding that would be generated, so the applicant has advised that the screen needs to be big enough so that it can be used as a mechanism to raise public awareness for fundraising campaigns and this would help to secure the long-term future of the Filmhouse.”

However, they added as it would cover part of the listed building including windows the installation would have a “detrimental impact” and obscure key architectural features.

Commenting, Historic Environment Scotland (HES) said while it “greatly welcomed the return of the Filmhouse” the screen “does not represent an appropriate long-term design solution commensurate with the listed building’s cultural significance”.

Committee convener Hal Osler said it was “unfortunate” the two elements had been combined in one application.

Chas Booth, who backed granting permission alongside Cllr Lezley Marion-Cameron, argued applicants had made a “significant effort to try and take on board the impact on the listed building”.

He said: “The fact the advertising structure is transparent, I think, means that the listed building can still be visible and still be seen through the advertising panel.

“I accept the advertising panel is extremely large . . . but I have a lot of sympathy for this applicant.”

Councillor Jo Mowat said: “Whether the screen is transparent, it won’t be transparent when it’s in use. This is to drive financial benefit for the preservation of the Filmhouse, which of course is something we all have great sympathy for.”

She added: “I don’t think this is a particularly complicated decision, I think it’s just an unpleasant one that we have to make.”

Councillor Alex Staniforth said it was “with a heavy heart” he agreed with planning officials the application should be refused. “I would prefer to support the Filmhouse in any way we can,” he added, “but looking at the reports I do think the officers are correct in their reasons for refusal and I don’t see a way of interpreting it differently.” 

A spokesperson for Filmhouse (Edinburgh) Ltd said following the decision: “For clarity, the Filmhouse renovation project is not in question because of the outcome at the Development Management sub Committee; the essential internal works Listed Building Consent is covered in a separate application submitted on 17^th September which was a contingency, in case the combined application was refused, and we hope the Planning Officers can deal with that application as soon as the process allows.

“We thanks the City Council for their support in getting Filmhouse up and running again.”

Cinema operators say they are aiming to open the doors again in March next year.

The Filmhouse has been boarded up since October 2022, after a drop in the number of cinemagoers and a “perfect storm” of financial difficulties led to the collapse of previous owners, the Centre for the Moving Image (CMI).

The new charity formed by former Filmhouse colleagues has raised over £2m so far for the re-opening and secured a 25-year lease from new owners, Caledonian Heritable.

One of its directors, Rod White, told councillors last month at a licensing meeting where the cinema’s bar licence was reinstated that the group now also had possession of “all the technical equipment that makes the Filmhouse the unique”.

By Donald Turvill Local Democracy Reporter

Edinburgh postman Andrew Davidson has effectively resigned his job to maximise chances of delivering on the major darts stage.

The 29-year-old former George Heriots School student has shot to prominence after winning the Welsh Open, an achievement that has just seen him ranked by Mastercaller website as – wait for It – global number ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY – in the World Darts Federation listings. He is also No 33 in the UK and Ireland rankings and climbing.

Winning the Welsh Open from a field of over 500 at Weston-super-Mare last month convinced Andrew, from the Blackford area of the Capital, to see how far his talents will take him on a full time basis.

“Essentially I have six months to prove myself and if it doesn’t work out I will have a job to go back to” says Andrew who started playing seriously aged 18 or, as he puts it, “as soon as I could legally go into a pub!”

By then he had long persuaded his parents to buy him equipment on which be practised relentlessly.

He adds: “It is not easy finding places around Edinburgh to play with one exception Murrayfield Sports Bar so I compete regularly out of Kirkcaldy and Falkirk while the Ship Inn, Dalkeith, have been kind enough to sponsor me.

“Winning a Super Series event in Portsmouth was a springboard into the Welsh Open and the next step for me will be to chase ranking points in the next few weeks everywhere from Bridlington to Lakeside to Hungary to Latvia so as to try to fulfil my goal of playing in world championships.”

Winning the Modus Super Series netted Andrew £3000 and he reckons he will need to reach the world’s top 64 to make a living and to give himself the best possible chance he says he will have to defy darts’ traditional image.

“Having a few drinks might be fine for some but for me I have to go on stage feeling the best I can be. Top darts players are a lot fitter than many people will think and my job as a postman helped in that respect” says Andrew, who reached the final of the first tournament he ever entered, losing to a former Scotland team captain.

Residents of a new housing estate have been left with a ‘path to nowhere’ after Tesco refused to allow it to be extended to their neighbouring store.

Developers Dandara were expected to created the link between its new North Berwick housing estate and the supermarket as a condition of building the new homes at its estate, in the town.

However a meeting of East Lothian Council’s planning committee this week heard the path now came to a dead end after Tesco said it had not agreed to the access route.

Committee members were told Tesco had concerns about health and safety, the cost of constructing and maintaining the route and said there were enough alternative access points for pedestrians in their car park.

Despite the path coming to an abrupt fenced in end at the edge of the land controlled by Dandara, East Lothian Council’s head of planning Keith Dingwall confirmed the local authority had adopted it as part of the path network in the estate.

Speaking as councillors were asked to allow the condition imposed nearly ten yeas ago on developers to create a through route to Tesco to be removed from planning permission, Mr Dingwall said he had held discussions with the supermarket chain’s planners who had made it clear they were not in favour of it.

He said: “Tesco have been consulted in regards to this planning application. The Town and Country planner advises Tesco is concerned that constructing a route would required a pedestrian crossing on the main route for vehicles into and out of their site which they say could have health and safety implications.

“They note that there could be insurance implications and note there could be significant costs involved in the construction of the route and maintenance.

“In addition Tesco is of the view that there is already adequate pedestrian routes on the site and for these reasons Tesco has confirmed they are not in favour of this pedestrian link being established.

“As Tesco are not in favour there is no realistic chance of this link being established.”

Councillors vented frustration at being asked to remove the condition with councillor Andy Forrest calling for developers to provide evidence they can deliver promises which are made.

He said: “This seems to be a common occurrence where developers have put in applications promising to do x, y and z and then come back to this committee asking for those conditions to be removed.

“We should have had a letter confirming Tesco had agreed to this path instead we have a path to nowhere.”

Planning convenor Norman Hampshire agreed saying: “We need to have an agreement where a path can physically operate, we have ended up with a path which is not physically possible to complete, because they had no agreement with Tesco. They should have had that at the time of planning consent.“

However Councillor Hampshire said he would ‘reluctantly’ agree to the condition being removed as the applicant could appeal if they refused warning rejecting the application would be ‘a folly’.

Councillor Shona McIntosh, said: “I find this really frustrating, it makes a mockery of the sustainable transport policy.

“The fact that what is clearly designed for a whole estate to get into Tesco and do their shopping without a car is being stopped, shows we need better powers to ensure when we put new housing in we can link them up to get around without a car.”

“I an going to abstain because I think it is ridiculous we cannot get a path.

And Councillor Jeremy Findlay said: “I will be voting against this as I feel conditions should remain in place and we should try and work with Tesco again however unlikely that may be.”

The condition to complete the path was removed by eight votes to three with one abstention from Councillor McIntosh.

Voting for the removal were councillors Norman Hampshire, Liz Allen, Donna Collins, Andy Forrest, Colin McGinn, John McMillan and Colin Yorkston. VOting against were Councillors Jeremy Findlay, Cher Cassini and Neil Gilbert.

Tesco have been approached for comment.

By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter

Presentations to the winners of various East of Scotland cricket leagues, both team and individual, were made during ceremonies at Grange Loan, home of Carlton CC.

These included Edinburgh South who were winners of the East Championship.

West Lothian Council will add its support to a growing national scheme which aims to improve life chances for people who have lived in care. 

A motion to recognise  Care Experienced as a protected characteristic was agreed by the full council. 

The decision means that council policies will now consider the experience of care when forming policies, recognising the need  to help level up the life chances of youngsters who grew up in care. 

West Lothian already has a pro-active record in working with young people with care and has now developed policies which help those transferring to adulthood, looking at services, and signposting continuing help that may be needed. 

 Research has shown that those who grow up in care can face a variety of difficulties through no fault of their own.    

A motion proposed by Independent Councillor Andrew McGuire and seconded by Lib Dem Sally Pattle  highlighted stark differences in life chances; from homelessness to unemployment right down to whether they can access the internet at home 

Care Experienced people are more than twice as likely to have experienced homelessness and more likely to earn three quarters of the salaries of their peers. 

They are over three times as likely to have not had a full-time job by age 26 and almost twice as likely to have no internet at home. 

The findings of the Independent Care Review carried out in 2020 led to the setting up of the Promise Scotland Team to ensure that “care experienced children would grow up loved, safe and respected.”  

A key recommendation to ensure children and young people reach their full potential is to ensure that Care Experienced is a protected characteristic. Since 2023, three local authorities – Falkirk, Stirling, Edinburgh – have joined 55 other organisations in Scotland in signing up.  

Councillor McGuire told the meeting:“I hope this goes through without any contention whatsoever because I think it’s a vitally important step forward for Care Experienced people. 

 “Care Experienced people have different life chances than other people and all the motion seeks to do is try and address some of this through some procedures that the council has.”  

 Councillor Pattle said: “ I think the facts in this motion speak for themselves. So for these reasons and more there is now a national movement working towards Care Experienced being recognised as a protected characteristic across the UK to help everyone who identifies as Care Experienced to reach their full potential.” 

By Stuart Sommerville Local Democracy Reporter 

The date of the council by-election in West Lothian has been set for 14 November. 

The poll, on a Thursday, will take place in the Whitburn and Blackburn ward following the resignation of  Councillor Kirsteen Sullivan after her election to Westminster. 

No candidates have been declared as yet, but one change agreed by the council’s Executive this week was not to open Polbeth village hall as a pollling station. 

This polling district currently contains nine electors, six of which were postal voters at the last council election.  These voters will be directed to Seafield Community Centre in a better use of resorces. 

Councillor Sullivan served the ward from 2017 until last week as one of two Labour councillors in a ward which has four including Labour veteran George Paul. Jim and Mary Dickson, for the SNP, are the other current serving councillors . 

By Stuart Sommerville Local Democracy Reporter 

West Lothian’s leader has backed CoSLA’s rejection of the controversial National Care Service plans. 

 Lawrence Fitzpatrick, a long-term critic of Holyrood centralisation, spoke out as it was revealed the plans had so far cost more than £28m. 

CoSLA, the umbrella organisation for Scottish Local Authorities, withdrew its support for the plan on Friday. The organisation’s health and social care spokesman, councillor Paul Kelly, said the bill did not represent the work that councils had contributed to the proposals. 

On Tuesday Councillor Fitzpatrick, Labour leader of West Lothian told the Local Democracy Reporting Service this week: “The costs are enormous”. 

Councillor Fitzpatrick urged ministers to listen to local authorities.  He told the LDRS: “The Scottish Government must recognise the flaws in their proposals for a National Care Service (NCS).  

“Fundamentally, the proposals do not directly address the existing challenges relating to how health and social care services are funded across Scotland.” 

Councillor Fitzpatrick added: “While we recognise  that there is a role for a national approach and consistency in relation to national improvement, standards and oversight it is not clear that this is best progressed through the development of a NCS.” 

At a recent meeting of the Executive the council rejected the proposals in response to the latest Scottish Government consultation.  Local SNP councillors called for a softening of the tone of the response.  Depute group leader Pauline Stafford reminded councillors  that Labour, nationally, had supported the foundation of NCS.  

Announcing the CoSLA decision on Friday, Councillor Kelly said:“Local government is committed to continuing our engagement with key areas of reform which can deliver improved outcomes for people, unpaid carers and our workforce. 

“We cannot, however, offer our support for the legislation brought forward at this stage” 

Ministers have said they are” extremely disappointed” that some in CoSLA  were trying to frustrate progress of the bill which has yet to have its second reading in Holyrood.  

Major unions including GMB and Unison also withdrew support for the plan in September. 

The plans for the NCS have undergone substantial redraw but still allow little real input by local authorities in the running of health and care services in the future.    

This lack of local oversight is at the core of Councillor Fitzpatrick’s opposition to the NCS. He told the LDRS: “Local people should be very concerned that the proposals for the National Care Service Board would remove members of a National Care Service Local Board, including locally elected members.  

“West Lothian Council would strongly oppose any proposals in relation to this due to the implications that this would have for local accountability. This is undoubtedly, removing local accountability and decision making from West Lothian and a form of centralising local services.” 

“The costs of creating and operating a new national Board with its associated infrastructure are enormous, particularly given the financial challenges facing local and front-line health and social care services are also a major cause for concern. 

 “The development of the National Care Service will also provide an additional layer of governance and reporting for health and social care services. Such significant changes are not necessary and distract from the significant and urgent investment that is required in social work and social care locally and across Scotland. 

 “COSLA has undertaken extensive discussions and negotiations with the Scottish Government concerning a number of ongoing challenges and risks in respect of the NCS. There is concern that these negotiations have not resulted in positive outcomes, with a number of matters remaining unresolved, including fundamental disagreement on many areas.” 

The Scottish Government confirmed on Tuesday in a written answer to Scottish Tory chairman Craig Hoy that £28,730,224 had been “spent on work related to the NCS”. 

The project – which would centralise adult social care and social work into a single body ultimately accountable to ministers – has been beset by delays and uncertainty over costs since it was announced by the Scottish Government in 2022. 

By Stuart Sommerville Local Democracy Reporter 

On Tuesday evening a reception was held at the City Chambers to officially welcome the City of Edinburgh’s new Makar, Michael Pedersen.

It was also an occasion to bid farewell to the outgoing Makar, Hannah Lavery, whose tenure now comes to an end – and to listen to some poetry from both.

Michael Pedersen the new Makar was hugely entertaining, a foretelling of things to come in this year of celebrations for Edinburgh’s 900th birthday – and he professed that he “loves a birthday”.

The Rt Hon Lord Provost, Robert Aldridge, said that Edinburgh was fortunate to have had Hannah Lavery as its Makar. He said she had a legacy to be proud of “speaking the truth and always while lifting otter’s, advocating and celebrating people, her peers and the city around her”.

Ms Lavery recited a new poem to her Nanna which had been written this year as a response to the Words from the Wards project at the Edinburgh Futures Institute (EFI) created in the former Royal Infirmary on Lauriston Place. In this initiative, EFI had asked those with past experience of the building as a hospital to write down their memories. Hannah’s Nanna had worked there for 32 years and she told her life story in verse with her mum and aunties in the audience.

Although admitting that Hannah will be a hard act to follow the Lord Provost continued: “I have no doubt that our new Makar is someone who will rise to the challenge and indeed enjoy that challenge. Like Hannah he is someone who shares a Portobello education and a serious work ethic. He is co-founder of NeuReekie! and is writer in residence at the University of Edinburgh.

“Michael’s work is honest fearless and witty with a strong focus on mental health and friendship.”

Michael did indeed rise to the challenge from the first moment he stepped up to the lectern. He had his bag with him (“not a lot of people in the room to be trusted”) and had his red clipboard with “Michael” in sparkles across the back (“it felt the occasion justified that”). He said: “It’ is glorious to be here amongst all these gorgeous faces, old friends, new friends, family, old teachers, lovers, dreamers, some of my favourite artists, my favourite writers, some of my favourite humans. Yikes!

“I am ambitious for this role. I want to ensure poetry remains with in the heartbeat of this extraordinary, complicated, quirky shape shifter of a capital city always punching above its weight.”

He recalled his youth – already told to us in this previous interview here – when he hid the poems he wrote in his golf bag (“wasn’t a keen golfer so it was a good place to leave them”).

He explained how he will begin: “This month, I’m going to be in three state schools to run workshops and launch a poetry competition on the theme of friendship, something really dear to me, those friends here, there and elsewhere. So I’m going to be in my old high school, Portobello. I’m going to be in Craigroyston. I’m going to be in Leith Academy. And I want to say a big thanks to the incredible literary charity, Superpower Agency, for all their panache in setting that up.”

As well as Michael and Hannah, several other former Makers attended the event at the City Chambers, including Ron Butlin, Christine de Luca and Stewart Conn, prompting the Lord Provost to ask what is the collective noun for a gathering of Makars? Ms de Luca suggested to us it could be a maudlin of Makars – any suggestions from readers will be welcomed. The Makar is a civic role which is selected by representatives of the Scottish Poetry Library, Scottish PEN, The Saltire Society, the City of Edinburgh Council and the Edinburgh UNESCO City of Literature Trust. The City of Literature Trust explain on their website: “The Makar acts as the city’s literary ambassador, and it’s their role to compose poems on Edinburgh, its people and aspects of life in the city, assist in the promotion of poetry in partnership with literary organisations, and select poetry for the Council’s website.”

Hannah also recited her poem, Tomorrow a Cathedral, an homage to St Giles Cathedral which is also celebrating its 900th birthday. She will – in her final act as Edinburgh Makar – perform this on 9 October at St Giles along with a brass band and the Edinburgh Ukrainian Choir – and young people from Abbeyhill Primary School and Portobello High School. Tickets are available below on Eventbrite.

Detectives are appealing for information following a housebreaking in Livingston. 

Around 7.50pm on Tuesday, 1 October, 2024 a house on Waverley Crescent was broken into however nothing was taken. 

Detective Constable Lynn Myles, Livingston CID, said: “Although nothing was taken, the owners were at home at the time of the break-in and have been left shaken by what happened. 

“We are appealing for the help of the public to trace those responsible and are particularly keen to speak to anyone who saw a dark coloured car and two young males in the area at this time. 

“It’s possible that they may so have been in the street or nearby in the days prior as well. We would be keen to anyone who may have seen a car or people in the area that seemed out of place or acting suspiciously. 

“Officers are making local enquiries but are keen to hear from anyone who may have captured any footage on dashcam or doorbells. 

“If you have any information that may assist our investigation, then please contact officers at Livingston quoting incident number 3358 of Tuesday, 1 October 2024. Alternatively, Crimestoppers can be contacted anonymously on 0800 555 111.” 

Edinburgh Zoo has announced the sad death overnight of Cleo the cheetah which had just arrived in August – and which was our cover star last month.

David Field, Chief Executive of RZSS, said, “In spite of the best efforts of our veterinary team and specialist animal carers, I’m sorry to say that Cleo passed away last night, following a short illness. We are still trying to establish what the cause of death is but we believe it is related to liver failure. We will know more after a post-mortem examination.

“Cleo wasn’t here at Edinburgh Zoo for long but in that time she made an amazing impression on all of the staff, vets, and visitors who met her. She will be sadly missed.”

The five year-old big cat had been brought from Fota Wildlife Park in the summer as a new “rock star” animal to replace the pandas. It was 24 years since a cheetah had last been on display at Edinburgh Zoo and plans were in place to introduce a male cheetah with hopes of breeding.

Click on the image below to read our August newspaper.

Singles champions for 2024 at St Serfs tennis club, Goldenacre, are Alex Lalos and Jane MacLennan.

Alex, pictured left, overcame the challenge of Luke Murray while Jane, right, took the honours against Chong Kwan.

I love curry. Maybe it’s in my genes. My mother was born in India, before moving to the UK at the age of nine, and it’s a go-to cuisine for all my family when eating out or in. Nothing beats the comfort of a bowl of curry and rice for me. Indian, Nepalese, Thai, or Sri Lankan – I’m not fussy.

So, imagine my delight when I stumbled upon an old favourite this summer – The Pakora Bar. Founded by three Edinburgh-based brothers with a vision to share their mother’s exceptional pakoras and curries, this family-run business has grown from a humble 12ft mobile kitchen. They first gained popularity at festivals like T in the Park, the Royal Highland Show, and the Fringe, which eventually led them to open their first permanent spot on Hanover Street.

I had been a regular at their city centre location – it was a healthier option for soaking up the effects of a late night out. However, after the Hanover Street branch closed, I assumed they’d gone the way of many hospitality ventures. As it turns out, they had simply relocated, and I was thrilled to rediscover them in their new Holyrood home, which they opened last year.

During this year’s Fringe, their street food restaurant proved to be my salvation. Nursing a monumental hangover after one of those “just one drink” nights turned into 3am, I needed a rice-and-curry remedy. The Pakora Bar fitted the bill. I opted for their fantastic value #FixForOne – three of their delicious pakoras with fresh salad and pakora sauce, and a curry served on rice or naan for just £15, available Monday to Friday, noon until 5 pm.

I spoke with two of the brothers, Mark, who manages the restaurant, and Paul, who handles catering. They were launching their new Mango Lassi Pale Ale, “Chakk De Phatte.” While my fragile state wasn’t up to sampling it that day, I returned a few weeks later to give it a proper try.

On this visit, I dined solo, (my friend had to cancel last minute, honest!). But I was in good hands – warmly hosted by the father of the family, John Singh, a charming turban-clad Sikh, and his wife Rajindar, who couldn’t have been more welcoming, with wonderful tales to tell. Meanwhile the brothers commanded their own sections, including brother Brian who was hosting the bar, and pulling many a Chakk De Phatte and making some mean cocktails. John’s grand-daughter, Paul’s daughter, was also getting in on the act, running their social media account and capturing customers’ reactions to the new drink.

The idea for “Chakk De Phatte” originated with John.  “Chakk De Phatte” – a phrase akin to “cheers” or “slàinte” – is Scotland’s first Mango Lassi Pale Ale. The recipe has been perfected by John’s sons over the years, and it truly complements the rich flavours of The Pakora Bar’s dishes. I might have been slightly overwhelmed by its presentation in a heavy tankard glass, but I rose to the challenge. In fact two pints went down too smoothly! The beer is sweet and fruity, with fresh mango notes, malty undertones, and a smooth finish. It paired beautifully with the spicy Punjabi Lamb Curry, slow-cooked for four hours, which was highly recommended by John.

Already shortlisted for The Scottish Beer Awards, “Chakk De Phatte” is available on tap and in cans at The Pakora Bar and select restaurants across Scotland. It’s poised to become the new go-to drink for curry lovers. Forget the wine; this beer is the perfect match for pakoras and curries alike.

For more information, visit www.thepakorabar.co.uk

Krua Thai: A Taste of Thailand in Liberton

Continuing with the curry theme, I have a long-standing wish to visit Thailand one day, a bucket-list goal that would allow me to fully immerse myself in learning to cook authentic Thai cuisine. But for now, I found the next best thing — a Thai cooking masterclass right here in Liberton.

The Krua Thai Cookery School is run by the delightful Rujira (‘Ru’) Herd from her home kitchen. Ru’s classes attract students from all corners of the world, including chefs from luxury yachts keen to uncover the trade secrets of traditional Thai cooking. She’s achieved a lot in her life — even cooking alongside the legendary Albert Roux. In just a couple of hours, my fellow two cooking companions and I learned authentic Thai techniques and recipes you’d expect to find in top Thai restaurants. And for those with a creative flair, you can even learn fruit and vegetable carving.

Whether you’re a seasoned chef or have never wielded a spatula, Ru has a knack for making everyone feel confident. She’ll equip you with the skills to whip up an impressive two-course dinner. We mastered dishes like Laab-e-saan, a spicy, herby salad made with minced pork; Giew Hang, delicate pork wontons with soy sauce and Kaw Pad, a simple but delicious fried rice with egg. The best part? We got to enjoy our creations in the comfort of Ru’s dining room, making the experience all the more rewarding.

For a truly unique and delicious culinary experience, I can’t recommend Krua Thai enough. Who needs a plane ticket when you can take your taste buds on a journey right here in Edinburgh?

https://www.kruathai.co.uk

There are baddies and goodies galore heading to the capital’s stages this month including hair-hoppers, missionaries and a Belgian sleuth on track to expose a murderer.

Lots to get through this month with the Playhouse, Festival Theatre and Royal Lyceum all bringing some cracking productions to the Capital. 

So without further ado, we start off with a show suitable for all the family, especially the youngest members of your clan, The Baddies (4-20 October) at the Lyceum. 

Suitable for three year olds and over and with a running time of less than an hour, the Baddies, based on the creations of Julia Donaldson and Axel Scheffler, are funny, silly and really, really bad.

Head to Grindlay Street if you are ready to meet the very worst Baddies in the world; a witch, a troll and an ancient ghost.

The Baddies love being bad. Watch as they roar, spook and cast wicked spells to try and scare a girl out of her wits but who will succeed? Or perhaps the girl is braver than they think…

With songs by Joe Stilgoe, The Baddies is ‘a laugh-out-loud riot’ for all the family.

Running Time under one hour. Tickets £11-£18  https://lyceum.org.uk/events/the-baddies#dates-and-times

At The Playhouse, Hairspray (7-12 October) marks the return of the beat you can’t stop. 

Starring Strictly Come Dancing favourite Joanne Clifton as the fierce yet fabulous Velma van Tussle, this production sees Hairspray royalty Brenda Edwards (famous for her turns as Motormouth Maybelle) making her directorial debut and hoping to bring new energy to the show.

Based on the John Waters film starring Divine, join big-hearted Tracy Turnblad and her new friends the spirited Seaweed and his sister Little Inez, heartthrob Link Larkin and the resolute Motormouth Maybelle as they strive to change the world with their timeless message of tolerance and the fight against racial discrimination.

Featuring the hit songs Welcome to the 60s, You Can’t Stop the Beat, Good Morning Baltimore and many more, Hairspray is always an uplifting night out. 

Running Time 2 Hours 30 Minutes including interval. Tickets £28-£83 https://www.atgtickets.com/shows/hairspray-the-musical/edinburgh-playhouse/calendar/2024-10-07

A week later those musical missionaries are back at the Greenside Place venue as Book of Mormon (15 October-2 November) returns for a three week run after the sell-out success of its last visit.

Not for the easily offended, this outrageous musical comedy from the creators of South Park, Trey Parker, Matt Stone and Bobby Lopez, follows the misadventures of a mismatched pair of missionaries, sent to a place that’s about as far from Salt Lake City as you can get.

Always a hot ticket, the New York Times called it, ‘The best musical of this century.’ See how many musical parodies you can spot hidden in the action. 

Running Time 2 Hours 20 Minutes including interval. Tickets £13-£105 https://www.atgtickets.com/shows/the-book-of-mormon/edinburgh-playhouse/

The following week, head to Nicolson Street, where Murder On The Orient Express (22-26 October) pulls into the Festival Theatre with a mystery to be solved. 

Following their sell-out tour of Agatha Christie’s ‘best-selling crime novel of all time’, And Then There Were None, Fiery Angel and Lucy Bailey bring Ken Ludwig’s adaptation of another Christie classic to the stage. 

It’s winter 1934 and an avalanche stops The Orient Express dead in its tracks. A murder. A train full of suspects. An impossible case. Trapped in the snow with a killer still on-board, can the world’s most famous detective, Hercule Poirot, crack the case before the train reaches its final destination and discover whodunit? 

Michael Maloney stars as the iconic Belgian sleuth and as always there’s a final twist, and this one is considered one of the author’s very best. 

Described as ‘gripping, tense and masterfully cryptic’, this brand-new production is a thrilling ride guaranteed to keep you guessing until the end of the line. Please note, it’s recommended for ages 12+.

Running Time TBC. Tickets £22.50-£47.50 https://www.capitaltheatres.com/whats-on/all-shows/murder-on-the-orient-express/2309#

Last on the list this time around is A Streetcar Named Desire (24 October-9 November).

The Lyceum brings the hit Pitlochry Festival Theatre production of Tennessee Williams’ classic to Edinburgh. 

After losing her family home and prosperous life, former southern belle Blanche Dubois moves into the shabby apartment of her younger sister Stella and her husband Stanley Kowalski in a poor neighbourhood in New Orleans.

Blanche and Stanley take an immediate dislike to one another. The conflict between them heats up as Blanche attempts to convince her sister to leave her abusive husband. Tensions mount with tragic consequences for Blanche.

Be warned, A Streetcar Named Desire contains ‘scenes that some people may find upsetting’, cautions the Lyceum. 

Running Time 2 Hours 35 Minutes including interval. Tickets £18-£38 https://lyceum.org.uk/events/a-streetcar-named-desire#dates-and-times

Heading south this month for a theatre break? If it’s something a bit more intriguing than the usual West End musical theatre fayre you’re looking for, the Charing Cross Theatre could be the place to be with a two week run of the Japanese play, Tattooer (14-26 October).

Seikichi is a young tattoo artist and former Ukiyo-e artist of high repute. His longtime wish is to ‘carve his soul into the skin of a beautiful woman’ but he has been unable to find a willing partner. 

Tattooer, by Takuya Kaneshima, which receives its UK premiere at the Charing Cross Theatre, explores what happens when Seikichi finally meets his ideal canvas… with audiences able to watch the ‘tattoo’ being applied live, during the interval.

Inspired by a short story by Junichiro Tanizaki, Tattooer is translated by Linda Hoaglund and aims to promote Japanese theatrical culture in the UK.

Running Time TBC. Tickets £12-£40 https://tickets.charingcrosstheatre.co.uk/WEBPAGES/EntaWebShow/ShowPerformance.aspx

Until next month, happy theatre going and keep up to date with all my latest news and reviews at MustSeeTheatre.com 

Líam  

Dinamo Minsk warmed up for their UEFA Conference League clash with Hearts on Thursday with a comfortable 2-0 win over mid-table Isloch in the Belarusian Premier League to be in second spot in the table, three points behind pace-setting Neman.

They have 47 points from 14 wins, five draws and one defeat and are in a good position to make a challenge for the title as Neman have 50 points from 16 wins, two draws and five defeats from 23 fixtures.

Third are Torpedo Zhodino who have 44 points from their 22 games, a record which includes 13 wins, five draws and four defeats and they are three clear of Dinamo Brest on 41 points from 23 starts.

Boni Amian, a 21-year-old midfielder from the Ivory Coast, netted both counters after 51 and 89 minutes for Minsk in the weekend win against Isloch who are 11th in the table, and the club are in form having won four of their last five games.

The Jambos squad was due to arrive in Baku on Tuesday night and interim manager, Liam Fox, has told fans that the club respects everybody and fears nobody.

Fox has watched footage of Minsk games and is fully aware that the Belarusian team can punish mistakes. Vadim Skripchenko’s men recently lost 1-0 to Vitebsk, but have subsequently posted to straight wins.

They have no injury worries ahead of the game and are determined to open their Conference League campaign with a victory after slipping down into the third-tier event following a 2-0 defeat on aggregate to Belgian side Anderlecht in a Europa League play-off.

Hearts also missed out on the Europa League after they were edged 2-0 on aggregate by Czech combine Viktoria Plzen in their play-off tie and the Tynecastle team’s domestic form has been poor, failing to win any of their last ten fixtures in all competitions.

Fox stressed that it is what Hearts do on the night which is so important and tweaks can be expected for what the Edinburgh-born coach believes will be a really tough tie.

Spirits were, however, lifted following Saturday’s last-gasp draw with Ross County, Lawrence Shankland scoring in the 96th minute, his first of the season, bundling the ball home from close range, in the William Hill Premiership at Tynecastle.

However, it was hard work last season, when the Jambos finished well clear in third at the close of the campaign, which earned Hearts the right to be in Europe and Fox would dearly love to see his boyhood favourites make a mark with a result on foreign soil.

Incidentally, the teams will play in an empty stadium, but that may suit Minsk as their players said in the build-up that they are used to it.

PICTURE: Liam Fox gives a media briefing. Picture Nigel Duncan

An historic pub which attracts visitors from around the world has won a fight to put solar panels on its roof in a bid to keep it operating in the future.

Staggs, in Musselburgh, has been owned by the same family for more than 150 years and is a category C listed building, but when Nigel Finlay applied to put  27 panels on its roof, East Lothian Council planners objected.

Planners said the plans would ‘harmfully alter’ the pub’s traditional slate roof and damage the ‘special architectural interest’ of the building.

However a meeting of the council’s planning committee heard from Mr Finlay’s daughter Katherine McKenzie that without the change the pub could find itself struggling with hefty electricity bills.

And she said the pub was listed more for its internal decor, which has been retained since Victorian times, than its exterior.

She told the meeting: “The Volunteer Arms, known as Staggs, has been in our family for 150 years and we recognise the importance of preserving its historic character but we also have to protect its future.”

Mrs McKenzie said that the solar panels would be embedded onto the roof with the Scottish slate removed to make room kept by the family for future repairs in a sustainable measure.

And she added the solar panels were expected to generate enough power to run the pub at a time when electricity bills were soaring.

Planning officers had recommended refusing planning permission and Listed Building Consent fo the panels to be introduced.

However councillors took a different view after hearing Mrs McKenzie’s appeal to be allowed to make the change.

Councillor Andy Forrest, local ward member, said he had drunk in the pub which attracted visitors from “around the world” and wanted to ensure future generations could drink there as well.

He said: “The listed building special interest of Staggs is mainly its interior and down to it being in the same family, and cared for, over generations.

“It is a well-respected, well-run and well loved pub and I want to ensure its future.”

Councillor Norman Hampshire said: “This is a pub which attracts visitors from around the world and probably one of a few left in Scotland which has remained in the same family’s ownership.”

And councillor Shona McIntosh added: “I would rather have a functioning pub at the heart of the community than an empty building. I don’t think if it was closed and boarded up people would pass and remark “look at its traditional slate roof”.”

The committee unanimously agreed to go against officers recommendation and grant planning permission and Listed Building Consent for the solar panels.

By Marie Sharp Local Democracy Reporter

Hearts have confirmed three fixture changes in the William Hill Premiership, including those against the Old Firm.

The club’s visit to Ibrox to square-up to Rangers will be a 5pm kick-off on Sunday, November 10, and will be shown live on Premier Sports.

The Tynecastle team host Celtic on Saturday, November 23, but the kick-off will now be 7.45pm and will be broadcast live on Sky Sports.

Aberdeen visit Tynecastle on Sunday, December 1 and this has now been confirmed as a 3pm kick-off with live coverage on Premier Sports.

Hearts’ home game against St Johnstone, moved to Sunday, December 22, is a 3pm kick-off.

Earth gains another Moon and the clocks go back one hour on the last Sunday at 2am.

Here’s a cool trivia question: How many natural satellites does the Earth have? One – the Moon – right? Well, from 29 September through 25 November, the correct answer will be two!

Asteroid 2024 PT5, recently discovered by ATLAS, will be captured by Earth’s gravity during that time and become a second Moon. Alas, it will be too small – barely 10m across – and faint to observe without a powerful telescope but it will be a second, albeit miniature, Moon throughout October.

The new Moon appears on 2 October at 7:49 pm in Virgo (The Maiden) beginning a new Lunar (synodic) month which will last 29 days, 17 hours and 58 minutes.

Lunar apogee (furthest from Earth) occurs on 2 October at 8:57 pm and takes the Moon to 406,515 km away from Earth—around 22,115 km further than average – subtending an angle of 29.4 arc-minutes. The first quarter of the new
cycle shows up on 10 October at 7:55 pm in Sagittarius (The Archer).

Lunar perigee (closest to Earth) on 17 October at 1:59 am finds the Moon some 357,179km away from Earth – around 27,221 km closer than average – subtending an angle of 33.4 arc-minutes. The full Hunter’s Moon makes an appearance on 17 October at 12:26 pm as it crosses from Pisces (The Fishes) into Aries (The Ram). October’s full Moon is also the largest supermoon of the year but not the last.

The Moon enters last quarter on 24 October at 9:03 am in Cancer (The Crab). Finally, there is a second lunar apogee (furthest from Earth) that occurs on 30 October at 0:04 am and takes the Moon to 406,142 km away from Earth – around 21,742 km further than average – subtending an angle of 29.4 arc-minutes.

On 19 October around 9 pm, the Moon conjuncts with the Pleiades star cluster (M45) in Taurus. Commonly known as the “Seven Sisters”, even naked-eye observers might spot more than seven members in this open star cluster. A pair of binoculars or small telescope will reveal countless additional members all of which lie around 444 light years away. Since it is a star cluster, we know that they all formed together around 100 million years ago when Earth was experiencing the dinosaurs of the Cretaceous period.

The Sun leaves Virgo (The Maiden) on 30 October at 7:04 pm and enters Libra (The Scales). Daylight shortens from 11:30 (11.506 hours) on 1 October to 09:15 (9.252 hours) on 31 October so we gain 2 hours and 15 minutes of night time by month’s end.

For the inferior planets: Mercury reaches its furthest point from Earth all year on 8 October and aphelion on 23 October. Since it starts the month at superior conjunction (behind the Sun), it is essentially lost to us for the whole of October.

Venus starts the month shining at -3.9 magnitudes in Libra (The Scales) and ends October in Ophiuchus (The Serpent Bearer), brighter at -4.0 magnitudes since it gets 28 million km closer to Earth. However it only emerges from the Sun’s glare in the last week of the month when it will be visible at very low altitude (less than 4 degrees) for around 30 minutes before setting in the south-west. Venus reaches aphelion on 30 October.

We fare much better with the superior planets with Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune all visible for large parts of the night all month long as shown on our sky map. Mars starts the month in Gemini (The Twins) and ends in Cancer (The Crab). The red planet gets 33 million km closer to Earth and brightens by 0.4 mag (around 45% brighter) by month’s end. It will reach western quadrature on 14 October and will lie 5 degrees east of the last quarter Moon on 24 October at 2 am. Jupiter reverses direction in Taurus (The Bull) – well, as seen from Earth due to orbital geometry anyway – on 9 October.

It begins the month at -2.5 magnitudes and increases brightness to -2.7 magnitudes by month’s end as it approaches closer to Earth by 59 million km. Saturn, in Aquarius (The Water Carrier), dims by 0.15 magnitudes as it recedes from Earth by some 49 million km over the month. On 14 October it will be within 0.1 degree south of the waxing gibbous Moon which will be 90% illuminated so will dominate the show.

Uranus in Taurus (The Bull) is visible all night and stands sentinel at 5.6 magnitudes even though is gets closer to Earth by 42 million km. Neptune, the blue planet, recedes by 35 million km but it is so far away that it barely impinges on observed brightness at 7.6 magnitudes. It is located in Pisces (The Fishes). As it rises on 15 October, it will be occulted by the waxing gibbous Moon illuminated to 96% making observation difficult until late evening on that day.

There are no fewer than 6 meteor showers active in October. Shooting star watchers use a scale called ‘Zenith Hourly Rate’ which is the number of meteors per hour if the radiant point were directly overhead. The ZHR, then, is a maximum anticipated activity and a bigger number (usually) means a better cosmic show. Alas, October’s meteor showers will feature lots of activity but not much of a show!

On 5 October, a meteor shower called the October Camelopardalids (281 OCT) will peak with a ZHR of 5. Although the meteor shower is named after the constellation Camelopardalis (The Giraffe), the radiant point is more like half way between Polaris in Ursa Minor (The Lesser Bear) and the tail of Draco (The Dragon). Since these constellations are circumpolar (they never set in the Edinburgh and Lothian sky), the meteors can be seen all night. Although activity is low, the waxing crescent Moon is only 7% illuminated making observing conditions favourable. The parent comet is unknown.

On 8 October, the Draconids (009 DRA) will peak with a better ZHR of 10. The parent comet is P/Giacobini-Zinner so the shower is also sometimes called the Giacobinids. The comet has a period of 6.6 years and is currently close to aphelion. Since Draconid activity is best with the comet at perihelion, we cannot expect any outbursts such as the last perihelion (2018) which had a ZHR of 150! If you wish to look, however, the radiant point is close to Rastaban in the head of the dragon. The waxing crescent Moon will be 30% illuminated.

On 11 October, the delta-Aurigid (224 DAU) meteor shower peaks with a paltry ZHR of 2. The radiant point is near Capella but with the low activity and the waxing gibbous Moon at 60% illumination, there will be very little too see. On 18 October, the epsilon-Geminid (023 EGE) meteor shower peaks with another weak ZHR of 3. The radiant point is near Castor’s hip but with low activity and the Moon just past full (97% illumination), there will be nothing much to see. The parent comet is C/1954 N1 (Ikeya).

On 20 October, we witness the Orionids (008 ORI) with a ZHR of 20. The parent comet is the most famous of them all: 1/P Halley. Alas, activity this year will be badly affected by moonlight with the waning gibbous Moon 84% illuminated. The radiant point is close to another famous object: Betelgeuse in Orion (The Hunter).

Finally, on 24 October we have the Leonis Minorid (022 LMI) meteor shower with a ZHR of 2. This meteor shower has the distinction of being the first found in photographic orbital data and the parent body is comet C/1739 K1 (Zanotti). The radiant point is between the hind legs of Ursa Major (The Great Bear) so is circumpolar. Low activity and the Moon at at last quarter (46% illumination) spoils the view.

Comet C/2023 A3 (Tsuchinshan-ATLAS) travels through 4 constellations during October starting in Leo (The Lion), crossing into Virgo (The Maiden) on the 5th, Serpens (The Serpent) on the 16th October and ending in Ophiuchus (The Serpent Bearer) from 20 October onwards. It will require binoculars and best visibility would be during closest approach to Earth on 13 October when it lies 70,724,459 km (0.47 AU) away. There is still a possibility that it will be bright enough to see with the naked-eye during evening twilight but, more likely, it will shine at 6.0 magnitudes and require binoculars. Look an hour after sunset in Virgo (The Maiden), low in the west.

Corona Borealis (The Northern Crown), you might recall from previous columns, hosts the recurrent nova T CrB better known as the Blaze Star. This should explode by year’s end and provide another jewel in the crown, of similar lustre to Polaris, near the star epsilon-13. At the time of our sky map it will be very low in the north west.

At the time of our sky map, some constellations visible are Cassiopeia (The Seated Queen) at zenith, Ursa Major (The Great Bear) in the north, Orion (The Hunter) rising in the east, Cygnus (The Swan) in the west, and Pegasus (The Winged Horse) in the south. The ecliptic hosts Gemini (The Twins), Taurus (The Bull), Aries (The Ram), Pisces (The Fishes), Aquarius (The Water Bearer) and Capricornus (The Sea Goat).

The “Summer Triangle” – Vega in Lyra (The Lyre), Altair in Aquila (The Eagle) and Deneb in Cygnus (The Swan) – is in the west. Circumpolar constellations – always above the horizon – include Cepheus (The King), Camelopardalis (The Giraffe), Draco (The Dragon) and Ursa Minor (The Lesser Bear).

Errata: In last month’s column, the consummate observer will have discovered the ephemeris showed the Moon at apogee twice. That was incorrect and resulted from an over-enthusiastic cut-and-paste by your present interlocutor’s fat fingers! Humblest apologies. The 5 September apogee was correct, the 9 September apogee was not. This month, though, the Moon is at apogee twice on 2 and 30 October.